English

Samson's Ransom

patenaude — Tue, 23 Sep 2025 18:36:33 +0000

Samson's Ransom

Monday, September 22, 2025

patenaude Tue, 09/23/2025 - 14:36

Associate professor of English, Sam Fallon (��/Matt Burkhartt)

Abstract

Milton’s worldly, prosaic Manoa has won few admirers, and his plot to ransom Samson in Samson Agonistes often elicits puzzlement. This essay situates Manoa in relation to the soteriological anxieties that Milton’s tragedy explores. Drawing on Freud’s psychoanalytic account of monotheism, I suggest that Manoa’s presence clarifies the paternal substitution realized in Samson’s elevation by God, but also threatens to unsettle it. Whereas Yahweh chooses Samson, Manoa’s love is fundamentally choiceless—an expression of an absolute bond. Reading Samson against two other Judges tragedies—Buchanan’s and Vondel’s plays about Jephthah’s sacrifice—I argue that Milton’s play reveals both the allure of chosenness and its psychological impasses. Manoa’s unconditional love offers a release from the drama of election. But Samson’s tragedy is that he can only reject it: to accept a love that demands nothing, that needs no choice, would mean giving up his most cherished wish—the wish to be chosen.

Main research questions

1.) What explains Milton's invention of a role for Manoa, in a work that otherwise hews closely to his biblical source?
2.) What position does Milton take in Samson Agonistes in relation to Protestant debates about salvation and predestination?
3.) What are the psychological implications of Milton's representation of fathers and sons?

What the research builds on

Milton's tragedy has occasioned a huge amount of commentary, but most of it dismissive of Manoa, who strikes critics as prosaic and worldly, unable to grasp Samson's higher, divine calling.

What the research add to the discussion

The essay shows how Manoa's bid to ransom his son emphasizes the difference between his paternal love--which is unchosen and unconditional--and the love offered by the substitute father, God, who first chooses and distinguishes Samson and then abandons him. Recognizing this opposition permits us to see how the tragedy subtly valorizes Manoa, and how that valorization articulates Milton's simultaneous discomfort with and attraction to the idea of divine election.

Samuel Fallon, "Samson's Ransom," Milton Studies 67.1 (2025): 153-79. https://doi.org/10.5325/miltonstudies.67.1.0153

Milton Studies (2025)

New English Programs Develop Professional Skills

rime — Fri, 05 Sep 2025 14:52:10 +0000

New English Programs Develop Professional Skills rime Fri, 09/05/2025 - 10:52

Geneseo Launches a New Academic Year

rime — Fri, 22 Aug 2025 13:15:17 +0000

Geneseo Launches a New Academic Year rime Fri, 08/22/2025 - 09:15

Best-selling Author Jeff VanderMeer to Deliver Annual Harding Lecture

patenaude — Wed, 20 Aug 2025 14:22:50 +0000

Best-selling Author Jeff VanderMeer to Deliver Annual Harding Lecture patenaude Wed, 08/20/2025 - 10:22

Emrys Donaldson

schacht — Tue, 12 Aug 2025 17:46:30 +0000

Emrys Donaldson

Assistant Professor of English and Creative Writing

schacht Tue, 08/12/2025 - 13:46

Emrys Donaldson is the author of the short story collection The Iridescents (Texas Review Press, 2025). His stories have recently been anthologized in Queer Little Nightmares (Arsenal Pulp Press) and published in venues such as LitHub and Electric Literature, among others. He received his MFA from the University of Alabama in 2019 and his BA summa cum laude from Cornell University in 2012. He joined the Geneseo faculty in 2025.

Literary Translation

barkan — Thu, 31 Jul 2025 15:06:27 +0000

Literary Translation barkan Thu, 07/31/2025 - 11:06

Sample Courses

History of the English Language
Literary Translation Workshop
Reading Transnationally

Popular Electives

Language and Culture
Languages in the Community
Methods of Teaching English to Speakers of Other Languages

Alumni Spotlight

Rachel Britton '18

Major: English (Creative Writing)

Career: Britton is a writer/editor/translator pursuing an MA in translation studies from the University of Iceland in Reykjavík. She recently published her first book of poems in translation from Icelandic, A Woman Looks Over Her Shoulder, by Brynja Hjálmsdóttir (Circumference Books, 2024).

Literary Translation

Why study literary translation at Geneseo?

This minor offers students the opportunity to expand their reading horizons globally while developing practical, intercultural skills that work across languages. Departmental connections to literary translation presses allow students to engage with practicing translators and works-in-progress as they explore literature from a range of cultural traditions and languages.

Request Info

Visit Geneseo

Apply